Our Menu
9 am to 2 pm Saturday & Sunday
Menu
Eggs Benedict
$13.00
English muffin, choice of corned beef, ham, bacon, banger sausage, mushrooms, smoked salmon (+3), and topped with poached eggs, house hollandaise, and green onion. Served with house breakfast potatoes.
Biscuits And Gravy
$13.00
House-made biscuit covered with McGarry’s own banger sausage gravy and two eggs your way
Pub Pancakes
$11.00
Three fluffy buttermilk pancakes served with two strips of bacon, and maple syrup.
McGarry’s Country Fried Steak
$17.00
Fried steak covered in house breading, smothered in sausage gravy, two eggs your way, house breakfast potatoes, side of hollandaise, and choice of toast.
Corned Beef Hash
$14.00
McGarry’s own house mix of corned beef, potato, bacon, roasted red peppers, yellow & green onion, topped with two eggs your way, and white sauce. Served with a choice of toast.
Chicken And Waffles
$15.00
Waffles, house-fried chicken tenders, hot honey, arugula, and maple vinaigrette with a side of sausage gravy.
Breakfast Burger
$15.00
1/4 lb beef patty, corned beef, bacon, Swiss, arugula, fried egg, side hollandaise, served with breakfast potatoes
McGarry’s Breakfast Flatbread
$15.00
Flatbread crust, white sauce, scrambled eggs, banger sausage, bacon, mozzarella, provolone, and green onion
McGarry’s Original Breakfast Sandwich
$12.00
Choice of: Waffle bun, croissant, English muffin or brioche bun, fried egg, choice of corned beef, ham, bacon, or banger sausage, choice of cheese, and served with house breakfast potatoes.
McGarry’s French Toast
$13.00
Three thick slices of cinnamon brioche French toast topped with banana, house caramel, and served with two strips of bacon.
Smothered Breakfast Burrito
$13.00
Red onion, ham, sausage, roasted red peppers, cheese blend, breakfast potatoes and scrambled eggs
Build Your Own Omelette
$13.00
Three egg omelette with choice of three ingredients (additional charge for each additional ingredient). Served with house breakfast potatoes and your choice of toast | Cheese: American, Irish White Cheddar, Swiss, Gouda, Pepperjack | Meats: Ham, Corned Beef, Bacon, Banger Sausage | Veggies: Mushroom, Green Pepper, Red Onion, Tomato, Jalapeño, Arugula
Sandwiches / Burgers
Reuben
$17.00
Slow roasted corned beef, swiss cheese sauerkraut, and 1000 island dressing on toasted black rye
Chicken Club
$17.00
Marinated grilled chicken breast, smoked gouda, smokehouse bacon, lettuce, red onion, tomato, and our rosemary aioli on a brioche bun
A.B.L.T.
$15.00
Avocado, smokehouse bacon, lettuce, tomato, and our rosemary aioli on toasted ten-grain wheat
Maple Plain Burger
$14.00
Burger Patty, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Brioche Bun | Add: Cheese, Bacon. Make It Impossible - plant-based meat
Salad / Soup
Soups and salads are served with house-made cranberry brown bread. Salads add: chicken, salmon, steak, anchovies
Potato & Leek Soup or Soup of the Day
$8.00
Mug of our signature creamy potato & leek soup topped with cheddar-jack cheese and bacon. Ask about Soup of the Day 8
Quinoa Salad
$14.00
Mixed greens, garbanzo beans, cucumber, tomatoes, red onion, quinoa, avocado, goat cheese, toasted almonds, and tossed with a house-made herb vinaigrette
Caesar
$11.00
Chopped romaine hearts, house-made dressing, parmesan, and garlic croutons
House Salad
$8.00
Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, shredded carrot, and your choice of dressing
Starters
Celtic Curds
$12.00
Wisconsin white cheddar curds served with Bushmills BBQ sauce
Irish Rolls
$13.00
Corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, in a wonton wrapper with a side of 1000 island
Blarney Stones
$13.00
Hard boiled egg, banger sausage, panko, herbs, and honey mustard
Thai Chicken Flatbread
$15.00
Chicken, chile ginger, red onion, broccoli, pizza cheese, cream cheese
Weekday Lunch
Served 11 am to 3 pm Monday through Friday
Shepards Pie
Roasted Vegetables, Braised Beef Brisket, Ale Gravy, Champ Mash, Irish Cheddar Cheese, Baguette
Half Sandwich & Soup
Tomato, bacon, grilled cheese / Tuna Salad or B.L.T & Mug o’ Soup
Soup & Salad
Mug O’ Soup with Garden or Side Caesar
Beef Commercial
Roasted Beef Brisket, whole grain wheat bread, Champ, Beef Gravy
Chicken Finger Basket
Three potato chip breaded chicken tenders served with fries coleslaw & choice of dipping sauce
Dubliner Meatloaf
McGarry’s house recipe with champ, fresh vegetables & Smithwick’s ale gravy
Burger Basket
Quarter-pound burger topped with American cheese served with fries & coleslaw
Meatloaf Sandwich
10-grain Wheat bread, a slice of McGarry’s house recipe meatloaf, caramelized onion, sun-dried tomato aioli, and fresh arugula, with chips, fries, or slaw
Chicken Caesar
Chopped romaine hearts, house-made dressing, shaved parmesan, garlic croutons, herb-grilled chicken breast
Fish & Chips
Lunch-size portion of our famous Fish & Chips.
Corned Beef and Cabbage
Lunch sized portion of Slow Cooked Corned Beef, Cabbage, Boiled Potatoes, House White Sauce
Grown Up Mac & Cheese
A Lunch size portion of our Grown Up Mac & Cheese - Cavatappi Noodles, 5 Cheese Sauce, Sun Dried Tomatoes, Green Onions, Herbed Bread Crumbs
Soups & Salads
Potato & Leek Soup
$9.00
Mug of our signature creamy potato & leek soup topped with smokehouse bacon and cheddar-jack cheese. Served with crackers and house-made cranberry brown bread
Soup of the Day
$9.00
Mug of our soup of the day - ask your server. Served with crackers and house-made cranberry brown bread
Smoked Salmon Salmon
$17.00
Smoked Salmon, Mixed Greens, Sherry Vinaigrette, Red Onion, Serrano Pepper, Goat Cheese, Cucumber and Walnuts
Quinoa Salad
$15.00
Mixed greens, Fresh Herb Vinaigrette, Garbanzo Beans,Cucumber, Grape Tomatoes & Red Onion, Quinoa, Avocado, Goat Cheese & Toasted Almonds
Caesar
$13.00
Chopped Romaine Hearts, House-Made Dressing, Shaved Parmesan, Garlic Croutons
House Salad
$8.00
Mixed Greens, Tomato, Onion, Cucumber, Carrot
Entrees
Panko Crusted Walleye
$25.00
Panko and Herb Crusted Walleye, Lemon Garlic Remoulade, Champ Mash Potato, and Asparagus
Chicken Cordon Blue
$21.00
Chicken stuffed with Ham and Cheese covered in Panko and baked to perfection, House White Sauce, Asparagus, and Champ Mash Potato
Braised Short Ribs
$27.00
Braised Short Ribs, Champ Mash, Roasted Vegetable, Short Rib Demi Glaze
Mushroom Rissoto
$19.00
Creamy Risotto, Wild Mushrooms, Herb Oil, Freshly Grated Parmesan Cheese
Shepherd’s Pie
$21.00
Beef Brisket, Herb-Roasted Vegetables, Beef Gravy, Champ, Irish White Cheddar, and Baguette
Corned Beef & Cabbage **
$22.00
Slow Cooked Corned Beef, Cabbage, Boiled Potatoes, House White Sauce
Fish & Chips
$21.00
Cod Loin, Harp Lager Beer Batter, Fries, Coleslaw, House-Made Tartar, House-Made Pickles
Grown-Up Mac & Cheese
$16.00
Cavatappi Noodles, 5 cheese Sauce, Sun Dried Tomatoes, Green Onions, Herbed Bread Crumbs. Add: Bacon, Banger Sausage, Beef Brisket, or Chicken
Short Rib Stroganoff
$24.00
House Pappardelle Pasta, Crema, Braised Short Ribs, Mushroom and Onion Mix, Herbs, White Wine, Demi served with Baguette
Dubliner Meatloaf
$22.00
McGarry’s House Recipe with a blend of Irish Banger Sausage, Beef and Steel-Cut Oats, Champ Potato, Beef Gravy, Fresh Vegetables
Starters
Poutine
$15.00
House Fries, cheese curds, Banger Sausage, Herbs, Ale Gravy
Irish Rolls
$13.00
Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut, 1000 Island, Wonton Wrapper
Chicken Tenders
$14.00
House Kettle Chip Breaded Chicken Tenders, French Fries, Choice of Sauce
Celtic Curds
$12.00
Wisconsin White Cheddar Curds, House-made Bushmill’s BBQ
Williams Wings **
$16.00
House Blend of Spices, Smoked, Fried to Perfection. Sources: Chile Ginger, Honey Mustard, Buffalo, House-made Bushmills BBQ, or Dry Rub
Blarney Stones
$13.00
Hard-Boiled Egg, Ground Banger Sausage, Herbed Bread Crumbs, Guinness Honey Mustard
Jalapeno Poppers
$13.00
Cream Cheese and Irish Cheddar Stuffed Jalapenos wrapped in Bacon and Glazed with Bushmills BBQ Sauce and served with Raspberry Coulis
Onion Rings
$7.00
Deep Fried Perfection
Burgers & Handhelds
All sandwiches are served with our house-made pickles and your choice of fries, kettle chips, or house-made coleslaw. Upgrade to onion rings, sweet potato fries, a mug of soup, salad, fresh fruit, and a gluten-free bun
Mcgarry’s Original Fried Chicken Sandwich
$17.00
House Breaded Fried Chicken, McGarry’s Sauce, Pickles, Lettuce
Smoked Brisket Sandwich
$17.00
Smoked and Sliced Brisket, Chimichurri, Pickled Onions, Chile Oil, Arugula
Mcgarry’s Smashburger
$16.00
2 Smash Patties, McGarry’s Sauce, Lettuce, Onion, American Cheese
Maple Plain Burger
$14.00
Burger Patty, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onion, Brioche Bun. Add: Caramelized Onion and or Mushrooms; Cheese; Bacon. Make it Impossible - plant-based meat
Curd Burger
$18.00
Burger Patty, Bushmills BBQ sauce, white cheddar curds, Smokehouse bacon, Brioche Bun. Make it Impossible - plant-based meat
Reuben
$17.00
Slow Roasted Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut and 1000 Island Dressing All On Toasted Black Rye
Fried Walleye Sandwich
$17.00
Crispy Walleye, Lettuce, Onion, House Pickles, Tartar Sauce on a French Roll
Chicken Club
$17.00
Grilled Marinated Chicken Breast, Smoked Gouda, Smokehouse Bacon, Lettuce, Red Onion, Tomato, Rosemary Aioli, Brioche Bun
Not Your Mama's Tuna Melt
$15.00
Spicy Tuna Salad, Smoked Gouda, Cajun Spice, Wheat-Berry Bread
A.B.L.T.
$15.00
Avocado, smokehouse bacon, lettuce, tomato, rosemary aioli, Wheat-Berry Bread
Flatbreads
Smoked Brisket Flatbread
$15.00
Smoked Brisket, Red Onion, McGarry’s Sauce, Cheese Blend, Chimichurri
Thai Chicken Flatbread
$15.00
Chicken, Chile Ginger Sauce, Red Onion, Broccolini, Pizza Cheese, Cream Cheese, and Crispy Won-ton Strips
Caprese Flatbread
$15.00
Farm Fresh Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Pesto, Balsamic
Diablo Chicken & Bacon Flatbread
$15.00
Diablo Ranch, Chicken, Bacon, Green Onion, 5 Cheese Blend, Fresno Pepper
Desserts
Rotating Bread Pudding
$9.00
Ask for today’s Chef-inspired flavor!
Guinness Chocolate Cake
$9.00
Scratch-made layered fudge cake, Guinness chocolate ganache, raspberry coulis, whipped cream
Banana Crème Brûlée
$9.00
Fixed Price Per Person Packages
Options
Paddy’s Package
$17.00
1 each: Standard Handheld, Standard Salad, Standard Sides
Dubliner Package
$22.00
1 each: Standard Entree, Standard Salad, Standard Dessert and 2 Standard Sides
Hibernia Package
$29.00
2 Standard Entree; 2 Standard Appetizers; 1 Prime Sides; 1 Prime Salad; 1 Standard Dessert
Prime Package
$35.00
2 Prime Entree; 2 Prime Sides; 2 Prime Appetizers; 1 Prime Salad; 1 Prime Dessert
Standard Offerings
Standard Appetizers
Chips and Sals | Chicken Tender | Chips and Queso | Chicken Wings
Standard Handhelds
Deli Sliders | B.L.T Sliders | Chicken Caesar Wraps | CheeseBurger Sliders | Deli Sandwiches ( Wheat, + Lettuce,Onion, Ham or Turkey )
Standard Entree
Mac and Cheese | ½ Chicken (Breast and Thigh) | Pulled Pork | Smoked Ham | BBQ Pulled Brisket | BBQ Pork Ribs
Standard Sides
Mash Potatoes | Boiled Baby Reds | Braised Cabbage | Coleslaw | Baked Beans | Green Beans and Carrots | Cranberry Brown Bread
Standard Desserts
Bread Pudding | Chocolate Cake | Muffins | Cookies
Prime Offerings
Prime Appetizers
Blarney Stones | Irish Rolls | Poutine | BBQ Pork Burnt Ends | Chips and Guacamole
Prime Salads
Quinoa Salad | B.L.T Salad | Cobb Salad
Prime Entree
Grown-Up Mac and Cheese | Steak Medallions | Dubliner Meatloaf | Lasagna | Pork Tenderloin | Corned Beef | Smoked Brisket | Sweet and Hot Fried Chicken
Prime Sides
Potato Salad | Asparagus | Herb Roasted Fingerling | Potatoes | Drunken BBQ Baked Beans | Potato Leek Soup | Fruit Tray | Irish Fried Rice
Prime Desserts
Assorted Dessert Tray | Double Layer Chocolate Cake | Pie (Apple, French Silk, Banana Creme)